You can change insurance brokers whenever you like. You don’t need a reason, and you don’t need your current broker’s permission. The cleanest time to do it is at renewal: the new policies start the day the old ones end, so there’s no gap, nothing to cancel and no cost.
Most people who move their insurance to Steve aren’t chasing a lower price. They’ve stopped hearing from their broker, calls take days to come back, or the business and family have grown and the insurance hasn’t kept up. If that sounds familiar, here’s how a switch actually works.
Switching at renewal
About two to three months before your policy renews, your new broker gathers the details, goes to the insurers and comes back with options. Once you choose, the new policy is set to start on the same day the old one ends. You tell your current broker in writing that you won’t be renewing, and that’s it.
Renewal is also the best time to fix anything that’s been bothering you about the coverage itself: limits that are too low, an umbrella that doesn’t sit over everything, a home office or a business vehicle the policy doesn’t know about.
Why not switch mid-term?
You can, but it usually costs you. Moving mid-term means cancelling the old policy part-way through, and most insurers then apply a short-rate penalty: they keep more than the unused share of the premium. Unless something can’t wait, it’s better to start the conversation now and have the new policies begin on your renewal date. That also gives your new broker time to do the work properly.
If you do cancel early for any reason, never cancel the old policy until the new one is confirmed in writing.
When to start
For a typical home and car, a month or two before renewal is plenty. Give it longer when things are more involved:
- High-value homes and cottages. Insurers may want an inspection or a rebuild-cost appraisal before they’ll quote, and that takes time to book.
- Businesses. Commercial insurers want details about your operations, revenues, vehicles and claims history. Starting 60 to 90 days ahead avoids a rushed renewal.
- Several policies with different renewal dates. Home, cottage, cars, umbrella and business policies can be moved one at a time, as each comes up.
What to have ready
You don’t need everything, but these speed things up:
- Your current policy documents or the declarations pages (the summary at the front)
- Any claims in the last five years, even small ones
- For vehicles: drivers, vehicles, and how each one is used
- For property: who is on title, recent renovations, alarms, and anything stored there for a business
- For a business: what you do, revenues, number of employees, and any contracts that require you to carry certain insurance
If you don’t know something, say so. A blank is better than a guess.
What needs to move with you
The policy is only part of it. When you switch, a few other things need to follow:
- Your mortgage lender needs proof of the new home or cottage policy.
- Certificates of insurance you’ve given landlords, customers or general contractors need to be reissued.
- Auto insurance cards (pink slips) for every vehicle.
- Payment plans. Make sure the old pre-authorized payments stop and the new ones start.
- Your umbrella. It has to sit over the new home and auto policies, so check the requirements line up or move it at the same time.
- Open claims stay with the insurer that had the policy when the loss happened, even after you switch.
A good broker handles this list for you, but it’s worth knowing what’s on it.
One step at a time is fine
Most of Steve’s clients started with one policy: a home, a business package, a cyber policy, a builder’s risk. Once they’d seen how he works, they moved the rest as each renewal came up. Over time, he lines up the renewal dates so the business and family insurance can be looked at together, which is where most gaps show up.
How Steve handles a switch
Steve starts by asking what isn’t working and what you own now: the business, the home, the cottage, the vehicles, any rental properties. He looks at your current coverage summaries and renewal dates, and works out which policy to move first. Steve and his team take care of the lender, certificates and payment changes. Then he reaches out before each renewal to ask what’s changed.
If you’re thinking about moving your insurance, book a review a couple of months before your next renewal, and bring your current policies.
Common questions
Will I be without insurance while I switch?
No, if it's done properly. The new policies are set to start the same day the old ones end. The one thing to avoid is cancelling or letting an old policy lapse before the new one is confirmed in writing.
Is there a cost to switching brokers?
Not at renewal. The old policy simply ends and the new one starts. Cancelling a policy part-way through the term is different: the insurer usually applies a short-rate penalty, keeping more than the unused share of the premium. That's why it's normally best to switch at renewal.
Can I switch in the middle of my policy?
You can, but it usually means cancelling the old policy and paying a short-rate penalty. Unless something urgent can't wait, it's better to start working with your new broker now and have the new policies begin on your renewal date.
Do I have to tell my current broker?
Yes. Let them know in writing before the renewal date that you won't be renewing, so the old policies aren't renewed and billed alongside the new ones. You don't need to give a reason.
Can I move one policy and leave the rest where they are?
Yes. Most people start with one policy, often the one where service has been the problem, and move the rest as each one comes up for renewal. Over time it's worth lining up the renewal dates so everything can be reviewed together.
Does my claims history come with me?
Yes. Insurers ask about past claims and can check them, whichever broker you use. Be upfront about them: an undisclosed claim found later causes far more trouble than one mentioned at the start.
